Food & Nutrition
Print|Email|Text Size: ||
Choosing the Best Food for Your Dog


With more attention being paid to the issues surrounding the safety and provenance of the foods humans eat, and with award-winning investigators like Michael Pollan and Marion Nestle writing insightful books on the topic—what Pollan refers to as the “Age of Nutritionism”—it is no wonder that consumers were questioning the way they feed their dogs well before this latest recall scandal. In an article in The New York Times Magazine (1/28/07), Pollan points out that a “potentially serious weakness of nutritionist ideology is that it has trouble discerning qualitative distinctions between foods. So fish, beef and chicken through the nutritionists’ lens become mere delivery systems for varying quantities of fats and proteins and whatever other nutrients are on their scope. Similarly, any qualitative distinctions between processed foods and whole foods disappear when your focus in on quantifying the nutrients they contain.” This point is underscored when one reads a label on a bag of kibble or a can of pet food and tries to understand exactly what the ingredients or nutrient sources are.

Bear in mind that most of the ingredients in pet foods are at the low end of the food chain; they come from whatever remains of the animal (be it chicken, pig or cow) not deemed fit for human consumption. These “parts”—heads, feet, bones, blood, beaks, lungs, ligaments—are either used for pet food or are converted for poultry and livestock feed, or even fertilizers. The consumer does not know the quality or source of the ingredient because it certainly doesn’t appear on the label, and few consumers know the difference between whole meat, meat by-product or meat meal. (For a detailed discussion, see Patrick in resources.)

Quality of the ingredients should be at the heart of this discussion of pet food. Nutrition is certainly important, but as Marion Nestle, PhD, nutritionist and author of What to Eat, says, “The problem with nutrient-by-nutrient nutrition science is that it takes the nutrient out of the context of food…” All of these factors are also important in our consideration of what and how we feed our dogs. Nutrient-by-nutrient thinking obscures the message that what we feed our dogs is more than an assemblage of ingredients, nutrients and additives, it is food—and it needs to be safe. But somehow we became convinced otherwise, afraid to step beyond the dictums promulgated by the pet food industry. Convinced that preparing our dog’s food ourselves, home cooking or supplementing a kibble diet with some of the “dreaded” table scraps would result in an unbalanced diet. Many of us feared that feeding anything other than commercially prepared food would harm our dogs.

As Christie Keith, who has written extensively on the subject, notes, “There is a lot of wiggle room in formulating a diet for your dog. Canines are, overall, rather forgiving nutritionally. That’s part of their success as a species.” So those of you who want to venture beyond the foods you have been using and either switch brands or perhaps prepare meals (cooked or raw), take heart. There are good alternatives—not only are there a few good commercial pet foods, but there also are easy-to-follow recipes, and even professionally formulated recipes devised by veterinary nutritionists (see resources). We’ll continue to write about healthful alternatives in future issues, as well as well as examining and analyzing the pet food industry’s practices and standards.




This article first appeared in The Bark,
Issue 42: May/Jun 2007
Claudia Kawczynska is The Bark's co-founder and editor in chief. thebark.com

Lettering by Darren Booth

CommentsPost a Comment
Please note comments are moderated. After being approved your comment will appear below.
Submitted by Brett | January 30 2010 |

Informative article. There are quality dog foods out there. Just stay away from by-products, grain fillers, and preservatives. I give my pup Newman's Own which he loves and is good for him as well. You may have to pay more, but it will ensure that your dog is healthier and will give you peace of mind.

Submitted by Christina chambreau | October 22 2010 |

It is wonderful that you did the research and made an educated choice of diet. Just like with people, some dogs can eat a high quality prepared food and be healthy, while others show many of the early warning signs of illness. If your dog needs a bath because of doggy odor, or has crud in the corner of the eyes in the morning, or has behavior issues, a better diet could be needed.

Make your choice of foods - fresh or processed, then carefully track the health of your dog. Keep a journal, tracking any illnesses as well as the early warning signs. The Healthy Animal's Journal makes it easy.
Dr. Christina Chambreau

Submitted by Christina chambreau | October 22 2010 |

As always, Bark is doing a great job addressing current dog issues.

When I lecture, one question people love to answer is how old their dogs lived decades ago. Their answers frequently echo Claudia's childhood dog who lived to 20. Now many dogs die at much younger ages and/or have severe health issues. While lots of research has been done, processed food, as Claudia says, just does not make health sense. In the 50 years I have been in the veterinary profession there have been many heath problems actually caused by insufficient research by food companies. In the 80s many cats developed blindness and hypertrophic cardiomyopathy because the processed food did not have the taurine needed by cats.

If you wanted your children to be maximally healthy, would you feed a wide variety of locally, sustainably raised fresh foods or mostly processed (canned, frozen, full of corn sugar)? Of course you would do the former. Just as with food for people, every individual dog and cat may need different food, so the key not mentioned in this article is the importance of tracking the specific symptoms to pick the best diet. I totally agree with Christie Keith that canines are, overall, rather forgiving nutritionally. I am so glad bark will be addressing brands, preparing meals (cooked or raw), or buying raw meat diets. I am thrilled dog guardians can look forward to many more healthful alternatives in future issues.

Submitted by Anonymous | November 19 2010 |

I feed my 35 lb German Shepherd mix Solid Gold Wolf Cub (soon to be Wolf King)as well ass Nature's Variety Raw (lamb, rabbit and bison) and my cats get Nature's Balance Reduced Calorie... Are these good brands? I try and stay FAR FAR AWAY from the grocery store brands...Yuck!

Submitted by Ryan Lau | April 6 2011 |

I'm getting a dog for the first time in my life, and as an imminent father, I have been obsessively researching various dog products. I came across Orijen by recommendations from friends and it seems to be widely regarded as a very high qualtiy dog food that is made from ingredients "fit for human consumption" in "human grade facilities." I'd love to make homemade dog food for my new pup, but I can imagine that this is not always feasible. My guess is that alot has changed in the pet food industry since 2007, and since 2007 was referred to as the "tipping point," I assume that means that things have changed for the better. Any insight into this would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

Submitted by Renee | June 2 2011 |

I started feeding my two dogs (6mo puppy and 7y spayed female) a homemade / sometimes raw diet about 4-6 mo ago. Especially when the puppy came home. Not exclusively, I still offer the kibble. I only give my 7y about an ice cube size portion in the morning and again in evening. She is free to fed the rest of the day-which has never been an issue before. We just came from the vet and she has gained 7 pounds in the past year or two! She has not been weighed in awhile so I don't know how recent the gain is. Now, she is getting a lot of treats the past 3 mo due to puppy (puppy gets treat for potty, she does too) but they are little tiny bites (half-pea size). Not enough to make 7 lbs. So, I'm left thinking that it is due to the homemade food. I know it is healthier for her (current batch is gr beef with pumpkin, spinach, raw egg, carrots) but weight gain is not! But would maybe 1/3 cup of raw food a day make that much difference in her weight? She has exercised more in the last 3 mo due to puppy than in years, but still the weight gain. Any words of wisdom?

Submitted by AgnesRichard29 | July 22 2011 |

I strive to react urgently and I try to opt for only experienced writing service.

Submitted by Helen Billet | November 27 2011 |

Excellent article. The one hurdle that people seem to face with feeding quality food to their dogs is price. Finding good coupons seem to help with that and I use a site that I check weekly to see if any coupons are available for the dog food that I use: http://petfoodtalk.com/dogfoodcoupons/. I very rarely pay full price for my dog food anymore.